COMPUTATIONAL TOPOLOGY ALGORITHMS FOR DISCRETE 2-MANIFOLDS

Wood, 2003

Category: Computational Geometry

Overall Rating

2.7/5 (19/35 pts)

This paper offers a specific algorithmic framework for localizing, measuring, and simplifying topological handles in discrete 2-manifolds, distinct from mainstream persistent homology...
This particular approach... could potentially offer a unique, geometrically-sensitive feature representation for specific applications in geometry processing or analysis of structured discrete data sets where the 'ribbon' concept is naturally relevant.
While the paper presents interesting algorithmic details... its methods appear largely superseded by the more general and robust framework of persistent homology.
The specific augmented graph structure and localized geometric computations add complexity without offering clear advantages over existing TDA tools for most modern applications...

The core algorithms for detecting and isolating handles in discrete 2-manifolds using augmented Reeb graphs and localized graph traversals... are robust and proven for their specific domain (geometry).
The specific blend of techniques... might not have been universally adopted or generalized beyond geometry processing.
The underlying concepts... could be abstracted and applied to complex discrete structures in other fields (e.g., networks, high-dimensional data representations)...
The topological features and structures... could be used as inputs, labels, or constraints for training ML models...

This paper's approach is heavily tied to the specific data structures and processing paradigms prevalent around 2003, primarily triangle meshes and regular scalar volumes...
The focus solely on handles (genus-1 features) is a limited view compared to modern topological data analysis (TDA) which considers features at all dimensions and scales simultaneously.
Its core algorithmic ideas were either overly complex/brittle for practical implementation or were quickly superseded by more general and robust techniques...
The major tasks addressed – identifying, measuring, and simplifying topology – are now largely handled by persistent homology.

Watch