Discrete Mechanical Interpolation of Keyframes

Yang, 2007

Category: Computer Graphics

Overall Rating

2.7/5 (19/35 pts)

This paper's specific numerical method for discrete mechanical interpolation using complex non-linear optimization, ad hoc regularization, and a slow relaxation process appears largely impractical and superseded by more robust modern techniques like Projective Dynamics or direct constrained solvers.
...the unique conceptual framing of artistic intervention as quantifiable "ghost forces" and the objective to minimize their magnitude and non-smoothness presents a potentially valuable design principle.
This principle could inform the design of objective functions in modern control or optimization methods (e.g., in robotics or constrained simulation) aiming to achieve desired states with minimal, graceful deviation from natural dynamics...

This paper's unique framing of artistic control in physics-based animation as minimizing "ghost forces" (non-physical interventions) within a discrete mechanical framework offers a potent, unconventional avenue for research in robotics and physical human-robot interaction (pHRI).
The objective function defined (Equation 4.8), which minimizes the magnitude and ensures the smoothness of these ghost forces subject to discrete mechanical constraints, can be directly repurposed.
In a robotics context, the system is the robot, the keyframes are desired robot poses or end-effector locations, and the "ghost forces" can be interpreted as the minimal external physical forces or deviations from passive dynamics required to steer the robot through these keyframes.

The core of the method lies in forcing a discrete mechanical system to deviate from its natural trajectory by adding "ghost forces" to satisfy keyframe constraints... attempting to corrupt this structure with arbitrary forces... creates a fundamental tension.
The method hinges entirely on solving a non-linear optimization problem (minimizing the cost function Jqk).
The discussion on regularization... highlights a major weakness. The need for ad hoc, problem-specific regularization terms just to make the solver converge... suggests numerical instability rather than a universally robust formulation.
Since 2007, the field has converged on more robust and efficient techniques for controlled physics simulation... Constrained Dynamics Solvers... Projective Dynamics...

Watch