Computational Methods for Behavior Analysis

Eyjolfsdottir, 2017

Category: ML

Overall Rating

3.4/5 (24/35 pts)

While the specific implementations (handcrafted features, multi-stage tracking, basic GRU-RNNs, binned prediction) presented in the paper are largely superseded by modern deep learning methods...
...the underlying architectural framework (BESNet) of jointly training coupled discriminative and generative recurrent networks with diagonal connections is not a fully saturated area.
The demonstrated ability of this architecture to spontaneously learn and separate high-level latent features (like identity) from low-level dynamics suggests a potential, albeit niche, path for developing more interpretable generative models...
...aimed at discovering hierarchical control policies or behavioral grammars within complex, dynamic systems, provided it is adapted with powerful modern components.

...the potential "hidden gem" lies specifically in the framework's design for learning and revealing latent, hierarchical behavioral control policies from spontaneous, interactive dynamics...
The key insight for unconventional research is the architecture's ability ... to spontaneously learn high-level abstract concepts (like fly gender or writer identity) in its higher hidden layers, while lower layers handle more immediate, low-level dynamics...
An unconventional research direction inspired by this could be developing interpretable AI agents trained on complex, naturalistic dynamical datasets... to discover the latent "grammar" or "intent" underlying the system's evolution.
This approach shifts the focus from purely predictive modeling or explicit control design to using AI as a scientific tool for latent discovery and interpretable simulation in domains where the underlying governing principles or control policies are unknown...

The paper's core methodological contributions... predate or were contemporary with the explosion of deep learning methods that have fundamentally changed computer vision and sequence modeling.
This paper likely faded due to the rapid emergence and clear superiority of deep learning techniques for object detection, tracking, pose estimation, and action recognition shortly after its publication/defense.
The tracking pipeline suffers from fundamental limitations... The handcrafted features... may not capture the full complexity... The structured SVM and simple GRU-based RNNs... lack the capacity and robustness of modern deep architectures...
Modern researchers should avoid investing significant time into reviving this paper's specific methodologies... because they have been fundamentally superseded by more robust, generalizable, and higher-performing deep learning approaches...

Watch