Generative Modeling: An Approach to High Level Shape Design for Computer Graphics and CAD

Snyder, 1991

Category: CG/CAD

Overall Rating

1.9/5 (13/35 pts)

This paper offers a specific, albeit niche, actionable path for modern research focusing on verified geometric computation.
By integrating the principle of propagating guaranteed bounds through compositional geometric operations (using interval analysis) into specialized domains requiring high assurance... one could potentially build systems that offer mathematically verifiable geometric properties.
However, this must confront the historical challenges of scalability and practical usability, likely limiting its applicability to highly specific, non-interactive tasks where correctness guarantees outweigh performance or ease of modeling complex, arbitrary shapes.

The core idea of defining shapes compositionally through a language of mathematical operators is powerful and resonates with modern computational graph paradigms.
the truly underexplored novelty lies in the systematic use of interval analysis and inclusion functions defined for each operator to achieve robustness and guaranteed bounds for geometric operations
The robust, interval-based computation techniques... are directly applicable to numerical analysis, scientific computing, formal methods, and safety-critical systems
A novel research direction could be to integrate this interval-based, compositional geometric framework into modern differentiable programming libraries

The fundamental definition of "generative modeling" has undergone a seismic shift... Snyder's deterministic, operator-composition framework is fundamentally misaligned with this dominant modern paradigm.
The reliance on a textual, C-based interpreted language (GENMOD) for shape specification was a critical barrier.
Interval analysis... is notoriously prone to producing wide bounds and suffering from the "curse of dimensionality," leading to slow computation for complex shapes
Modern procedural software... offers a visual, modular, and highly flexible way to define complex geometric operations... effectively providing a much more usable and extensible "generative" framework

Watch